Contents
Key Takeaways
- A freelancer suits a straightforward site when you can supply the words, photos and direction yourself, and usually costs less.
- An agency suits a site that must bring in leads: strategy, copywriting, design, build, tracking and SEO handled by a team, usually for a higher fee.
- The biggest freelancer risk is a single point of failure: illness, a full diary or a career change can leave your site without support.
- The biggest agency risk is paying for process you do not need, or being handed to junior staff after the sale.
- Whoever you hire, make sure the domain, hosting, site and accounts are in your name from day one.
Hire a freelance web designer when you need a straightforward site, can supply the words, photos and direction yourself, and want to keep costs down. Hire a web design agency when the site must bring in leads and you want strategy, copywriting, design, build, tracking and SEO handled by a team, with someone accountable for the result. Both can build an excellent website. The right choice depends on how much of the work you want to do yourself, how complex the site is, and how much risk you can accept if one person becomes unavailable.
What Each One Does
A freelance web designer is usually one person who designs and builds the site, sometimes with a trusted network of other freelancers for writing or photography. You work directly with the person doing the work.
A web design agency is a team: typically a strategist or project manager, a copywriter, a designer, a developer, and often an SEO specialist. You work with a lead contact who coordinates everyone.
Side by Side
| Freelance web designer | Web design agency | |
|---|---|---|
| Typical cost | Lower | Higher, with more included |
| Who you work with | The person doing the work | A lead contact and a team |
| Copywriting | Often left to you | Often included |
| SEO and tracking | Varies widely | Usually part of the scope |
| Speed | Depends on one person's diary | A team can work in parallel |
| Range of skills | One person's strengths | Several specialists |
| Support after launch | Depends on availability | Usually a support plan or retainer |
| Risk if something goes wrong | Single point of failure | More continuity, more process |
When a Freelancer Is the Better Choice
- Your site is small and simple, such as a few pages describing your services.
- You can write the content, supply photos and make decisions quickly.
- You have found someone whose past work for similar businesses you love.
- Budget is tight and you would rather put the difference into advertising.
- You want a close working relationship with one person.
When an Agency Is the Better Choice
- The site needs to bring in leads, and you want copy, structure and calls to action planned around that.
- You do not have time to write the content or manage the project.
- The site is larger or more complex, with booking, a CRM connection, an online store or many service and area pages.
- You want SEO foundations, tracking and speed handled properly from the start.
- You need a firm launch date and ongoing support you can count on.
Risks to Check With a Freelancer
- Availability: illness, holidays or a full diary can stall your project. Ask how they handle absence and who covers support.
- Gaps in skills: a gifted designer may not be a strong developer, writer or SEO. Ask exactly what is and is not included.
- Ownership: make sure the domain, hosting and site are in your name, not theirs.
- Maintenance: agree who updates plugins, fixes problems and makes changes after launch, and at what cost.
Risks to Check With an Agency
- Bait and switch: the senior people who pitch may not be the ones who build. Ask who will do the work.
- Paying for process: discovery workshops and long approval rounds add cost. Make sure each stage earns its place.
- Lock-in: some agencies build on systems only they can maintain, or keep the hosting and domain in their name. Insist on ownership and access.
- Templates sold as custom work: ask what is designed for you and what is a reused theme.
Questions to Ask Either One
- Can I see sites you built for businesses like mine, and talk to those clients?
- Who writes the copy, and who supplies the photos?
- What SEO work is included: page titles, structured data, redirects from my old site, speed?
- How will you track calls and form submissions after launch?
- What is the timeline, and what happens if it slips?
- Who owns the domain, hosting, design files and accounts?
- What does support cost after launch?
Our guide to choosing a web design company covers portfolios, contracts and how to compare quotes in more depth.
What It Costs
Freelancers usually charge a fixed project fee or an hourly rate; agencies usually quote a fixed project fee with more included. Our guide to what a website costs covers typical ranges for builders, freelancers and agencies, plus running costs after launch.
For reference, our own web design plans are fixed prices with copy, design, build, tracking and SEO foundations included:
| Plan | Price | What it covers |
|---|---|---|
| Launch | $3,500 one-off | Up to 5 pages |
| Growth | $6,500 one-off | Up to 12 pages, with booking or a CRM and a blog |
| Custom | From $12,000 | More than 12 pages, or an online store |
Sites up to 12 pages go live in 14 days, or you don't pay the balance, and the domain, site, content and accounts are in your name from day one.
The Bottom Line
If you need a simple, attractive site and can do the writing and organizing yourself, a good freelancer is often the best value. If you need a site that brings in leads, built to a deadline with copy, SEO and tracking handled, an agency usually earns its higher fee. Either way, judge them on sites they built that bring their clients business, not on how they look in a portfolio.
Free tool
Page speed checker
Check how fast your current site loads on phones before you brief a designer, so speed is in the plan from the start.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is a freelancer cheaper than an agency?
Usually, for the design and build alone. But compare like with like: an agency quote often includes copywriting, photography direction, tracking and SEO foundations that a freelancer would leave to you or charge for separately.
Can a freelancer build a site that ranks on Google?
Yes, if they know technical SEO and you supply strong, specific content. Many talented freelancers focus on design and build; ask exactly which SEO tasks they include and who writes the copy.
How do I know if an agency will hand my project to juniors?
Ask who will design and build the site, ask to speak with them before you sign, and ask for sites they personally worked on. A good agency answers plainly.
What if I already have a freelancer I like?
Keep them for updates and small changes, and bring in specialists for the parts they do not cover, such as copywriting, SEO or paid ads. Make sure someone owns the goal of turning visitors into leads.