Contents
Key Takeaways
- Decide what you need before you shortlist: the result you want, your budget, and which channels matter most for your buyers.
- Judge agencies on how they will measure leads and revenue, not on how many services they list.
- Ask for examples from businesses like yours, a clear plan for the first 90 days, and who will actually do the work.
- Google's own advice on hiring an SEO is a good checklist for any agency: ask about past results, timeframes, your industry and how they communicate.
- Walk away from guaranteed rankings, secret methods, long lock-in contracts and reports with no lead data.
To choose a digital marketing agency, decide first what result you need and what you can spend, then shortlist agencies that are strong in the channels your buyers use. Ask each for examples from businesses like yours, a written plan for the first 90 days, and how they will measure leads and revenue. Choose the one whose plan and reporting you understand, not the one with the longest list of services.
Decide What You Need First
Before you talk to anyone, write down three things:
- The result. More calls, more booked appointments, more online sales, more quote requests. Put a number on it.
- The budget. Agency fees plus ad spend, and how long you can wait for results from slower channels like SEO.
- Where your buyers look. Searching Google when something breaks, comparing options over weeks, asking AI tools for recommendations, or scrolling social media.
This stops agencies selling you the channels they prefer instead of the ones you need.
Specialist or Full-Service?
| Option | Good when | Watch for |
|---|---|---|
| Specialist (for example SEO or Google Ads only) | One channel brings most of your customers | Gaps between suppliers if you hire several |
| Full-service agency | You need search, ads, website and reporting working together | Depth in your most important channel |
| Freelancer | Small, well-defined jobs | Capacity, holidays and continuity |
| In-house hire | Steady, long-term workload and budget for salaries | Cost, tools and breadth of skills |
Questions to Ask Every Agency
Google's guide on whether you need an SEO lists questions worth asking before hiring: examples of previous work, what results to expect and in what timeframe, experience in your industry and location, how long they have been in business, and how they will communicate changes. They work for any marketing agency. Add these:
- Who will do the work? Meet the people, not only the salesperson.
- What will you do in the first 30, 60 and 90 days? Ask for it in writing.
- How will you measure success? Expect leads, cost per lead and revenue, not only clicks and rankings.
- What do you need from us? Access, approvals, content, time for calls.
- What happens if results do not come? Ask about guarantees and their conditions.
- Who owns the accounts and assets? Your ad accounts, analytics, website and content should be yours.
How to Compare Proposals
Put proposals side by side and check:
- Is the plan specific to you, or could it be sent to any business?
- Are fees and ad spend separated so you know what goes to the platforms and what goes to the agency?
- What exactly is included each month, in tasks and hours, not just channel names?
- How long is the commitment, and how do you leave?
- What does the report look like? Ask for a sample.
The cheapest proposal is rarely the best value. The right question is which one is most likely to bring customers at a cost per customer you can afford.
Red Flags
- Guaranteed first-page or first-place rankings. Nobody controls Google's results.
- Secret methods they will not explain.
- Long contracts with no exit, even if agreed results are missed.
- They keep ownership of your ad accounts, website or analytics.
- Reports with no lead or sales data, only impressions and rankings.
- No questions about your business, your margins or your customers before quoting.
What a Good First 90 Days Looks Like
- Month 1: tracking set up for calls and forms, an audit of your website and accounts, a baseline of current leads, and quick fixes.
- Month 2: the main campaigns or page improvements live, early results reported honestly.
- Month 3: a review of cost per lead by channel and a plan for the next quarter, moving budget to what works.
If you cannot see what changed and why by the end of the third month, ask hard questions.
How We Work
Our digital marketing services start with a channel plan built from your budget and goals, showing the leads we expect from each channel before you sign. Every plan carries a written guarantee, and after the first three months you can leave with 30 days' notice and no penalty. For typical fees, see our guide to what a digital marketing agency costs.
Free tool
SEO audit
Run a free audit of your website before you talk to agencies, so you know what needs fixing and can judge their proposals.
Frequently Asked Questions
Should I hire a specialist or a full-service agency?
If one channel matters far more than the rest, such as local search for a plumber, a specialist can be the better fit. If you need several channels working together, a full-service agency saves you coordinating several suppliers. Either way, check they are strong in the channel that matters most to you.
How much should I budget for an agency?
Start from what a customer is worth and how many you need, then compare that with the agency's fees plus any ad spend. Our guide to digital marketing agency pricing shows typical fees by channel.
How long should an agency contract be?
Long enough for the work to show results, often three to six months for SEO, then month to month. Be wary of 12-month lock-ins with no exit if the agreed results are not met.
What should a monthly report include?
Leads and sales by channel, cost per lead, what was done that month, what changed and what is planned next. Rankings and traffic are useful context, but they should lead back to leads and revenue.